Oxylabs vs ProxyShare: Proxy Prices, Scraping APIs and Workload Fit

ProxyShare has substantially lower published rotating-residential package rates. Oxylabs offers a broader documented combination of mobile proxies, granular targeting, managed access, structured scraping and remote browser automation. The better purchase depends on the selected product, actual local inventory, accepted output and the integration work you need the provider to remove.

This comparison corrects two misleading shortcuts: ProxyShare’s Long Acting ISP tariff is not its rotating-residential tariff, and ProxyShare does offer separate Web Scraper and SERP APIs. Compare raw proxies with raw proxies, then evaluate the managed products separately. A low per-GB rate does not establish that two exits or extraction services perform the same work.

1. Quick Verdict

Shortlist ProxyShare for a bounded raw-proxy cost pilot when its required locations and targets are available and your application already owns retries, parsing and quality control. Its $9/10 GB rotating-residential order has a smaller purchase total and lower published unit rate than Oxylabs Starter, although the quantities and validity models differ.

Shortlist Oxylabs when a specific capability matters: a documented mobile network, ZIP/coordinate/ASN filtering, dedicated ISP allocation, supported structured parsing or a Playwright/Puppeteer-compatible remote browser. Confirm that the exact SKU includes that capability. A broader catalog does not automatically improve the performance of a raw residential request.

Shortlist both for managed extraction. ProxyShare’s current APIs invalidate a blanket “proxies only” description. Evaluate each target’s output schema, billing definition, rendering and destination support. The smaller listed commitment may be useful for a pilot, but public headline allowances are not guaranteed equivalent records.

2. Research Scope & Comparison Rules

We checked public official pricing, product documentation and policies on October 5, 2026. We did not purchase traffic, complete authenticated checkout, run a controlled speed/success benchmark, audit sourcing or measure support response times. Charts use documented package arithmetic or explicit hypothetical consumption rather than numerical editorial scores.

Keep four layers separate: raw proxy transport; managed page access; structured extraction; and interactive browser execution. Price each at its actual unit—GB, IP/time or billable results—and include the maintenance work that remains with your team. Published monthly billing and 30-day validity are also different contract descriptions; do not infer identical renewal, rollover or activation rules.

3. Provider Profiles

RAW PROXIES • MANAGED COLLECTION • REMOTE BROWSERS

Oxylabs

Oxylabs publishes residential, mobile, datacenter and shared/dedicated ISP products alongside Web Unblocker, Web Scraper API and Agent Browser. It is worth evaluating when the desired network filters or managed layer can replace meaningful application work. Each product has its own price, access rules and billing definition.

Show Oxylabs pros & cons

Explore Oxylabs

LOWER PUBLISHED BANDWIDTH RATES • STATIC AND API OPTIONS

ProxyShare

ProxyShare publishes rotating residential, Long Acting ISP, static residential and datacenter rentals, plus a separate unlimited-residential offer. Its current catalog also includes Web Scraper API and SERP API. The low visible package totals make a small feasibility pilot accessible, while product identity, validity, local availability and policy terms still require careful confirmation.

Show ProxyShare pros & cons

Explore ProxyShare

The Oxylabs review and ProxyShare review cover each catalog in more detail. Homepage images provide orientation; their displayed wording should not substitute for the researched tables or the final account offer.

4. Proxy Types, Coverage & Targeting

Pool totals have no identical counting window established here and are not simultaneously connected inventory. Test the required city, network and target instead of treating a larger headline as proof of better access. “195 countries” and “195+ locations” also use different labels, so they should not become a geographic coverage ratio.

Oxylabs advanced IPv4/IPv6/OS options may require KYC. HTTP/3 support uses a suitable MASQUE client; an ordinary HTTP proxy setting does not automatically make the application’s traffic native HTTP/3. Verify protocol and client compatibility before buying for that requirement.

ProxyShare documents restricted target categories and says its service is unavailable in mainland China. Confirm actual target permission and availability before paying; a supported country exit does not mean every site in that country is accessible. An “ISP” label likewise does not establish a mobile carrier, dedicated allocation or identical geographic inventory.

5. Rotating Residential Pricing

The frequently quoted ProxyShare $0.80-to-$0.35 grid belongs to Long Acting ISP, shown separately below. Using it for rotating residential understates the latter’s current prices. Similarly, a homepage lowest-price teaser does not establish the smallest purchasable order.

ProxyShare’s $9 purchase provides 10 GB, while Oxylabs’ $30 Starter provides 5 GB monthly. That establishes the published purchase and unit-rate difference, not equal quality or a success-rate advantage. For large orders, confirm metering conventions, top-ups and the precise meaning of the TB label rather than assuming every billing system counts bytes identically.

ProxyShare GB cards also display “Unlimited Bandwidth.” Budget the explicitly stated GB allowance and resolve the contradictory wording with support. Unlimited simultaneous sessions is not unlimited traffic. Confirm when validity begins, how unused balance is treated, renewal behavior and all checkout fees; no non-expiring balance or rollover promise was established.

6. Static, ISP & Mobile Pricing

At 100 ISP addresses, Oxylabs lists $130/month shared and $270/month dedicated. Those are allocation choices, not equivalent exclusivity. The $3.50/GB mobile headline requires the $2,500/715 GB Corporate package; it is not the rate of a $30 Starter purchase. Confirm carrier inventory and required location separately.

Long Acting ISP describes longer sessions while a peer remains available, not permanent ownership of an address. Confirm sharing, session replacement and supported geography. Do not compare its bandwidth price directly with a dedicated per-IP rental without estimating the bytes and number of simultaneous identities your application needs.

Oxylabs ISP “unlimited bandwidth” is subject to fair use. Shared ISP documentation reduces concurrency after 50 GB/IP in a cycle. Dedicated ISP text states 100 GB/IP but includes aggregate examples that do not reconcile; resolve the threshold in the account or contract. ProxyShare’s separate unlimited-residential headline starts at $68.38/day with randomly assigned countries, but the qualifying package, throughput and complete fair-use terms were not verified. It is not an unrestricted substitute for metered geographic targeting.

7. Charts & Utilization Economics

The charts use actual offer units and explicit hypothetical assumptions. They replace editorial numerical scores that would suggest a measured comparison. Package size, term and utilization matter alongside the published unit rate.

Estimate bandwidth from the actual workload. A hypothetical 10,000 requests averaging 1 MB each use roughly 10 GB under decimal arithmetic; 20% additional equal-size requests raise that to roughly 12 GB before overhead. Browser assets, retries and uploaded traffic can change the total materially. Observe provider usage rather than estimating from the size of the final CSV alone.

For a managed API, divide all collection and maintenance costs by accepted unique records. One billable response can contain many records, and a successful response can still miss required fields. A low nominal per-result price is useful only when the result definition, schema and acceptance quality fit.

8. Managed Scraping & Browser Tools

Oxylabs offers different managed layers

Web Unblocker manages page access and returns raw content; your parser remains responsible for arbitrary structured fields. Its regular packages include $75/8 GB, $325/38 GB and $660/88 GB, excluding temporary coupon offers. Traffic-based success billing includes upstream and downstream bytes under its rules; raw-proxy prices should not be used to estimate that managed layer.

Web Scraper API adds supported structured extraction, rendering, scheduling, batches, custom parsing and cloud integration. Micro is $49 monthly, Starter $99 and Advanced $249 on the reviewed pricing page. Micro per-1,000-result card rates vary by target: Amazon $0.50, Google $1, other unrendered $1.15 and rendered $1.35. These are not one universal rate or an allowance applying to every target.

Public API allowance tables do not always reconcile with pricing-card arithmetic. For example, $49 at $1.15/1,000 gives approximately 42,608 results, while another public table lists a different quantity. Confirm the effective account tariff and billing definition instead of promising a headline result count. Oxylabs documents 2xx/4xx as billable successful API responses, with system-failure classes excluded; accepted output remains a separate test.

The current browser pricing path redirects from Headless Browser to Agent Browser. Published plans are 50 GB/$300, 100 GB/$550 and 300 GB/$1,410 monthly. Playwright, Puppeteer and CDP-compatible tooling is documented, along with proxy access and browser/CAPTCHA capabilities. This remote browser is distinct from receiving rendered HTML or sending limited browser instructions to an API.

ProxyShare now has separate scraping APIs

ProxyShare advertises rendering, JSON/HTML, headers/cookies, custom browser instructions, CSS/XPath parser presets, scheduling and delivery to S3/GCS. These are meaningful capabilities, but we did not execute them or authenticate each plan entitlement. Its “successfully delivered results” language needs a concrete definition covering rendering, empty output, retries and target-specific schema.

The separate SERP API default cards list $17/15,000, $52/50,000, $128/150,000 and $300/400,000 results. Verify engines, locales, pagination, schema and what counts as a result. Neither this nor Web Scraper API is included merely by purchasing raw residential bandwidth. Proxy extraction through Open API is also a different operation from retrieving parsed website data.

For a wider collection shortlist, see our web scraping tools guide. Our Bright Data vs ProxyShare and IPRoyal vs Oxylabs comparisons explain other bandwidth and managed-product models.

9. Sessions, Authentication & Integration

Oxylabs supports rotation or sticky residential configurations, with up to 24 hours advertised. ProxyShare’s residential pricing uses up-to-24-hour wording, while its Long Acting ISP comparison describes rotating residential sessions up to 120 minutes. Resolve that discrepancy for the selected SKU. Neither maximum setting guarantees uninterrupted peer availability or dedicated ownership.

ProxyShare user/password access requires a corresponding product sub-account. API proxy extraction uses source-IP allowlisting; static products can have different extraction/authentication paths. Its guidance recommends separate session values for concurrent workers rather than sharing one session across all threads. Validate replacement behavior, country filters and the application’s network source before scaling.

Oxylabs raw residential documentation includes proxy-user and allowlist controls, while advanced filters may require approval. Use credentials scoped to the workload, protect tokens server-side and redact proxy URLs from logs. Test one permitted request, verify the exit and content locale, then introduce the intended session and concurrency settings.

A proxy and tunneling configuration changes how requests reach a destination. Protocol support alone is not device-wide privacy protection. For a browser-specific workflow, check how the browser, TLS verification, cookies and authentication interact with the chosen integration.

10. Performance & Accepted-Output Costs

There is no controlled benchmark in this article proving that either provider is universally faster or more reliable. Latency and success depend on the target, geography, session, product layer, rendering, concurrent load and acceptance definition. A provider-wide percentage does not measure your required complete records.

Test empty results, localized pages, consent dialogs, unavailable products and changed pagination. Record request failures separately from parser rejection. Reduce concurrency or apply bounded backoff when the target or provider rate-limits you; larger advertised pools and unlimited session labels do not remove the destination’s limits.

Also test recovery after a peer disappears, a browser run fails or a scheduled export is delayed. Make ingestion idempotent so repeated delivery does not duplicate data. Keep accepted samples and provenance to identify whether a repair changed the meaning of an output field.

11. Workload-Specific Recommendations

For price intelligence, validate product variants, currency, stock and observation time. For search monitoring, verify language and the actual result locale. For ad checks, validate the returned placement rather than a nonempty page. These acceptance rules can matter more than a small nominal bandwidth difference.

Our proxy provider guide, Bright Data vs Oxylabs and Oxylabs vs Webshare provide context for alternative raw and managed models. The proxy comparison tool can organize a shortlist; validate account-specific terms and workload results separately.

12. Support, Security, Trials & Refunds

Oxylabs plan cards list 24/7 support and account-management options; ProxyShare advertises support and integration guidance. Those labels do not prove a guaranteed reply or repair time. Agree on escalation, target failures, parser ownership, billing reconciliation and an SLA where production needs one.

Oxylabs publishes sourcing, KYC and trust materials; ProxyShare publishes privacy, usage and policy documents. Marketing anonymity or sourcing language is not an independent no-logs audit or a security guarantee. Review data-processing terms, permissions, destination access, logging and retention for your requirements. We have not independently audited either network.

The Robots Exclusion Protocol specification describes robots.txt interpretation and notes that it is not access authorization. Respect the target’s applicable permissions and policies, minimize unnecessary personal data and keep credentials out of shared outputs.

Trial access is product-specific

Oxylabs advertises a Web Scraper API trial up to 2,000 results, a Web Unblocker trial of 1 GB/up to 10,000 results, and a datacenter free plan. Agent Browser trial access requires sales contact. Do not infer an automatic unrestricted residential or mobile trial from those separate offers.

ProxyShare’s Web Scraper API default Trial card shows 1,000 results and 30-day wording. Its proxy FAQ advises arranging a sales trial; a fixed automatic 500 MB/1 GB raw-proxy trial was not verified. Ask about eligibility, expiry, permitted targets and enabled features for the exact product.

Refund rules need their dedicated policies

Oxylabs generally requires eligible first-purchase requests within three calendar days, with no policy breach, chargeback or prior refund. Usage caps apply to specified products rather than uniformly: residential/mobile, dedicated ISP and managed products list percentage thresholds, while shared ISP and some datacenter sections differ. Dedicated datacenter Enterprise purchases have separate final-sale/error rules. Confirm the exact SKU instead of assuming a universal money-back guarantee.

ProxyShare’s generic FAQ says products are non-refundable, but its dedicated policy provides limited exceptions: inability to connect unresolved 48 hours after support contact, system-wide downtime over 24 consecutive hours, duplicate payment and discretionary exceptional cases. Misconfiguration, local software/network conflicts, extensively used or older active orders and promotional/trial purchases face exclusions. Approval remains conditional; neither “never refundable” nor “unconditional refund” accurately describes it.

Before buying or canceling, confirm renewal, unused balances, validity start and access to exports. Save order IDs, confirmations and evidence of material faults. Stop scheduled traffic and protect required results before changing the account state.

13. Strengths & Tradeoffs

If your requirement is personal-device VPN protection, our NordVPN vs SafeShell and NordVPN vs Surfshark guides compare that different service model. Proxy protocol support alone does not establish the same device-level coverage.

14. Frequently Asked Questions

15. Final Verdict & Purchase Checklist

Choose ProxyShare when its lower published raw residential package cost survives a pilot on your required targets and locations. Keep rotating residential, Long Acting ISP and static rentals separate. Its current APIs also belong on a managed-collection shortlist if their schema and terms fit.

Choose Oxylabs when a documented filter, mobile SKU, dedicated allocation, supported parser or remote browser removes necessary work. Validate the specific feature and billing unit rather than buying a larger catalog on reputation alone.

1. Define permitted targets, fields, locations and acceptance rules.
2. Select the raw, managed or browser layer and exact product SKU.
3. Confirm allocation, validity, access requirements, sharing and all fees.
4. Run a bounded pilot and calculate complete accepted-output cost.
5. Resolve policy discrepancies, production support and renewal before scaling.